A HIPAA Violation? - WSVN-TV - 7NEWS Miami Ft. Lauderdale News, Weather, Deco

A HIPAA Violation?

Posted: Updated:

If you are perfectly healthy, you are lucky. If you have a medical condition, you probably don't want everyone to know. So is it legal for someone to release it so a group of people can know it? It's why one woman called Help Me Howard with Patrick Fraser.

WSVN -- People have animals for different reasons, but Madeline Athanas's dog Sandy is not just a pet, it's a life changer.

Madeline Athanas: "She just helps me in an hourly bases to be able to function normally, to be able to go outside and not be afraid."

Many people consider their dogs priceless, but Madeline says she can also put a price tag on her trained service dog.

Madeline Athanas: "If someone kills her, they have to pay restitution over $38,000 in the state of Florida. Florida takes service animals very seriously."

But of course some people don't take service dogs seriously and don't want them around, included in that group is Madeline's condo association.

Madeline Athanas: "And they said 'Madeline, you are OK to rent but not your dog.' That's what started it."

To enable Sandy to move into the condominium, Madeline had to file a complaint with the Federal Government and Broward County. She won, decided to buy a condo here and as a result, this document forced the association to allow Madeline's service dog to move in. Some members of the association didn't take that well.

Madeline Athanas: "It's been ruthless. They have been ruthless, with retaliating against me."

The latest incident came when Madeline tried to take Sandy to the monthly condo board meeting, just like she has for the past three years. This time, the association president blocked the door.

Madeline Athanas: "And he says, 'Madeline, you can't go to the meeting. Why not? Because of your service dog.'"

The president had apparently planned the confrontation because Hollywood police had been called ahead of time. The Hollywood officer was standing there as the condo manager walked up and told everyone standing around about the medical disability Madeline has that requires the service dog.

Madeline Athanas: "She didn't say it once, she said it three times. I was mortified. I was horrified that somebody would disclose confidential information."

Fortunately for Madeline, the police officer understands the law regarding service dogs and let Sandy into the meeting. But now, because of the condo manager blurting out her medical information, everyone in the association knows Madeline's disability.

Madeline Athanas: "She read in my file confidential medical piece. It's private medical information about someone's disability. I think it was malicious, it was intentional and it was defiantly retaliatory. Absolutely."

Madeline had to turn over her medical records to the association so they could see why she needed Sandy with her. She is stunned that someone who had access to that information would reveal that information to the residents.

Madeline Athanas: "I don't know if it's a HIPAA violation."

Well Howard, under HIPAA, it's against the law for people in the medical field to reveal your private medical information, but can a condo manager blurt it out to residents?

Howard Finkelstein: "This is not a HIPAA violation. It mostly covers healthcare providers who are regulated under HIPAA, but it's a violation of the agreement that Madeline and the association made allowing her to move in with her dog. And even if they didn't have that agreement, you can't release private medical information. If you do, you can be sued for violating someone's right to privacy."

We spoke to the condo manager. When we asked her if and why she released Madeline's information, she told us she had no comment, to call their attorney.

Instead we called her boss in Texas. In a statement they said, "Since this incident, the resident and her service animal have been allowed to attend numerous meetings without incident. This event has provided an educational opportunity for the community and our managers."

Madeline Athanas: "She is my life. She is my life."

Madeline is now ready to move on with her life. The damage done by the association can't be changed but she hopes those people who have come after her can change.

Madeline Athanas: "I pray for these people. I think they are evil spirited from the get go. People here have been evil."

Patrick Fraser: "Now Howard said you can sue someone if they reveal confidential information. To collect, you have to have damages such as releasing information that cost you your job or in some cases, you can collect if you are emotionally damaged.

What might be better for Madeline to do to convince her association to be quiet, file another complaint with with the county human rights section. She has done that and they are now investigating.

A big mouth giving you a big headache? Need us to be of service? Contact us. We will dog them until they do the right thing and keep quiet.

  • Out for JusticeMore>>

  • Alfred McCormick

    Alfred McCormick

    Saturday, July 26 2014 1:00 AM EDT2014-07-26 05:00:26 GMT
    Minister Alfred McCormickMinister Alfred McCormick
    He was a man of God, but early one morning Minister Alfred McCormick was gunned down in the street like a criminal. Maybe because a crook thought he was a crook he was looking for. As Patrick Fraser tells us on tonight's Out For Justice, detectives are determined to find his killer, but they need your help.
    He was a man of God, but early one morning Minister Alfred McCormick was gunned down in the street like a criminal. Maybe because a crook thought he was a crook he was looking for. As Patrick Fraser tells us on tonight's Out For Justice, detectives are determined to find his killer, but they need your help.
  • Qualecia James

    Qualecia James

    Friday, July 11 2014 11:30 PM EDT2014-07-12 03:30:24 GMT
    Qualecia James (right) and her daughterQualecia James (right) and her daughter
    Last March, an afternoon out with friends ended in a barrage of bullets for a pregnant Miami Gardens mother. As Patrick Fraser tells us on tonight's Out for Justice, detectives made an arrest in the case last week, but their work is far from over, and they need your help to bring in the rest of the killers.
    Last March, an afternoon out with friends ended in a barrage of bullets for a pregnant Miami Gardens mother. As Patrick Fraser tells us on tonight's Out for Justice, detectives made an arrest in the case last week, but their work is far from over, and they need your help to bring in the rest of the killers.
  • Benoit Lessard

    Benoit Lessard

    Monday, June 16 2014 11:13 AM EDT2014-06-16 15:13:54 GMT
    He bought his little spot in the sun. Retired Canadian Benoit Lessard loved to spend winters in South Florida, but as Patrick Fraser tells us on tonight's Out for Justice, a man with a gun turned his retirement heaven into hell. Fifteen years later, police are still trying to solve this cold case.
    He bought his little spot in the sun. Retired Canadian Benoit Lessard loved to spend winters in South Florida, but as Patrick Fraser tells us on tonight's Out for Justice, a man with a gun turned his retirement heaven into hell. Fifteen years later, police are still trying to solve this cold case.
  • 7News InvestigationMore>>

  • Captain of Controversy

    Captain of Controversy

    Capt. Francesco SchettinoCapt. Francesco Schettino
    In Italy this week, the captain of the Costa Concordia began pre-trial hearings he hopes will convince a judge that the deadly shipwreck was an accident and not a crime. Earlier this year, investigative reporter Carmel Cafiero traveled to Italy for an exclusive interview with Captain Schettino and now has a special assignment report on what he will be telling the court.
    In Italy this week, the captain of the Costa Concordia began pre-trial hearings he hopes will convince a judge that the deadly shipwreck was an accident and not a crime. Earlier this year, investigative reporter Carmel Cafiero traveled to Italy for an exclusive interview with Captain Schettino and now has a special assignment report on what he will be telling the court.
  • Till Death Do Us Part

    Till Death Do Us Part

    Thursday, November 7 2013 11:54 PM EST2013-11-08 04:54:26 GMT
    Alejandra Apraez said her wedding was ruined when the florist she hired did not show up. Alejandra Apraez said her wedding was ruined when the florist she hired did not show up.
    There is very little that will match a bride's wedding day -- a day, months, even years in the planning -- and one South Florida woman's wedding was ruined when the florist didn't show up. Why? A death ... but was there a death? Tonight, investigative reporter Patrick Fraser has the amazing story in a report we call "Till Death Do Us Part."
    There is very little that will match a bride's wedding day -- a day, months, even years in the planning -- and one South Florida woman's wedding was ruined when the florist didn't show up. Why? A death ... but was there a death? Tonight, investigative reporter Patrick Fraser has the amazing story in a report we call "Till Death Do Us Part."
  • Blackwater Fever

    Blackwater Fever

    It was a terrible form of malaria that killed two men. Turning their internal organs black. In south Florida we have almost wiped malaria out but now the concern -- it's spreading around us and could hit us. As...
    It was a terrible form of malaria that killed two men. Turning their internal organs black. In south Florida we have almost wiped malaria out but now the concern -- it's spreading around us and could hit us. As Patrick...
  • Help Me HowardMore>>

  • Can't Help Kids Learn to Swim

    Can't Help Kids Learn to Swim

    Monday, July 28 2014 11:37 PM EDT2014-07-29 03:37:03 GMT
    It's part of being a parent: teaching your kids to ride a bike, to play sports, to swim. But how would you feel if you were told, "Stop teaching your child to swim?" When it happened to one South Florida father, he was stunned, and turned to Help Me Howard with Patrick Fraser for some answers.
    It's part of being a parent: teaching your kids to ride a bike, to play sports, to swim. But how would you feel if you were told, "Stop teaching your child to swim?" When it happened to one South Florida father, he was stunned, and turned to Help Me Howard with Patrick Fraser for some answers.
  • Found Savings Bonds, Can't Find Owner

    Found Savings Bonds, Can't Find Owner

    Wednesday, July 23 2014 10:57 PM EDT2014-07-24 02:57:35 GMT
    It's what some people dream about: finding an envelope filled with money. One South Florida woman did find it in a parking lot, but she wasn't dreaming of riches. She was determined to find the owner. She couldn't, so she called Help Me Howard with Patrick Fraser.
    It's what some people dream about: finding an envelope filled with money. One South Florida woman did find it in a parking lot, but she wasn't dreaming of riches. She was determined to find the owner. She couldn't, so she called Help Me Howard with Patrick Fraser.
  • Finding a Burglar

    Finding a Burglar

    Monday, July 21 2014 11:39 PM EDT2014-07-22 03:39:48 GMT
    Loretta Clark's diamond necklace.Loretta Clark's diamond necklace.
    When his wife passed away, he was devastated. Today he feels even worse, because a necklace she loved, that was left for him, was stolen by a crook who broke into his home. So many people in South Florida are crime victims, but what can you do? It's why he called Help Me Howard with Patrick Fraser.
    When his wife passed away, he was devastated. Today he feels even worse, because a necklace she loved, that was left for him, was stolen by a crook who broke into his home. So many people in South Florida are crime victims, but what can you do? It's why he called Help Me Howard with Patrick Fraser.
Powered by WorldNow

WSVN-TV
Sunbeam Television Corp
1401 79th Street Causeway
Miami, FL 33141

Switchboard: (305) 751-6692
Newsroom: (305) 795-2777

Can't find something?
Connect with us here:
Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 WorldNow and WSVN. All Rights Reserved.
For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.